Since 2012, the crowds of gather at OLIO, — the best-kept secret in St. Louis


More than 20 million people traveled the Two Lane back roads of America to St. Louis for the World’s Fair in 1904. It’s where they saw new inventions, experienced different cultures, tasted new foods, and celebrated our accomplishments as a human race.

These days, those same state routes continue to lead adventure seekers to the city and its monuments like The Gateway Arch, the steps of the capital, and Busch Stadium for a Cardinals game. But right now, we want to talk about what’s cookin’ in the kitchen at one of the best-kept secrets in town.

In the Historical Botanical Heights neighborhood of South St. Louis sits a 1930’s Standard Oil Filling Station. Inside, Chef Ben Poremba is pulverizing garbanzo beans into a thick paste and flash frying octopus tentacles. You read that correctly — fried octopus in a filling station.

A dish like that should be served and enjoyed in a space just as unique and individual as it is. Step inside OLIO.



In 2012, as part of an urban renewal endeavor, Ben repurposed the gas station and its many charming features for his Israeli themed-restaurant, OLIO. You can see how Ben kept with Standard Oil’s traditional red, white, and blue color palette on the exterior. The garage, once used for performing oil changes and routine maintenance, now seats guests, a full-service bar, an herb garden, and an extended patio.

Inside the decor is simple with subtle nods to the buildings shop history. Notice the utility lamps hung by extension chords over the bar, the mix of the rusty workshop and marble tables, and the large garage door which is open when the weather allows. Don’t forget to catch the desk lamp chandelier in the garage too!

The fresh bouquets of herbs and candles throughout contrast yet complement the original brick and polished concrete floors. The fusion of mechanic and Mediterranean doesn’t sound like it would work, but these pictures don’t lie.

FUN FACT: Ben also purchased the 1890’s house next to OLIO for his sister restaurant, ELAIA. It’s the former home of Mr. Kinsworthy — the original owner/operator of the filling station!


By rescuing these two side by side, well-constructed buildings, two new businesses have found a home in the new St. Louis.

When you visit OLIO (or ELAIA) and feel like walking off your braised lamb shoulder dinner, you’re only a few blocks away from the Missouri Botanical Gardens and Tower Grove Park!



It’s fitting that inside this space where cans of motor oil were kept on the shelves, now have been replaced with bottles of olive oil. The bread served at OLIO is shaped and baked by hand using freshly-milled Missouri-grown wheat and a custom-made hearth oven. 

Bread isn’t the only way this restaurant pays homage to the past — they use a 500-year-old Sicilian recipe for a sweet and sour sauce called agrodolce which is served with their eggplant caponata. While this type of cuisine may seem overwhelming to those who prefer their basic burgers and fries, we promise there’s no reason to be intimidated by slow-roasted meats, pickled veggies, and unfamiliar sauces. Isn’t the point of traveling to vacate your life and try new things? Start with their charcuterie board then ease into the hummus, smoked trout, and bacon wrapped dates.

After the meal, kick back with an aperitif or a bottle of St. Louis’ best brew outside in the herb garden/patio. We highly recommended it!

Urban renewal is a trend we enjoy most on our travels. It’s a healthy sign to see a community with an appreciation of their past and intentionally making room for it in their future. It’s a type of storytelling that we can all benefit from — both with our minds and stomachs.

Share a restaurant you’ve enjoyed on Two Lanes that was located in a uniquely renovated space so we can all learn a little more about places like OLIO!


For more leads on where to eat + explore FOLLOW us on INSTAGRAM

Learn more about OLIO HERE

See the menu


Our newest ceramic white diner mug has a unique wrap design featuring a vintage scene and one of our favorite sayings “Pickin’ America”. SHOP NOW!



5 thoughts on “Dine Inside This 1930’s Standard Oil Filling Station”

  1. Peter McAlley

    Hi Mike and Frank, me and Anna came from Australia to meet you both but you were out of town still it was great to see your shop we left 2 bottles of south australian wine and some other things for you both and Dannie so we hope you enjoy them.I still love your show,what about coming to OZ to do a show before you stop doing this we have a lot of old stuff hear as well OZ has been going since 1776 with white people and other people from the world. I hope you can reply to this thanking you Peter McAlley its all the best to you all.

  2. Jeff Person

    I’m a big fan of the show and really like the two Lane stories about old places around the country. A couple of buddies and I rode up the natchez trace to Nashville in April, and visited your store there. You must sell all the good stuff in your Iowa store , I didn’t see near his much stuff for sale as I expected. Do you ever resell any of the old motorcycles after you fix them? I’d love to own an old British bike. Is there a website that I am missing out on where are you sell the good stuff?

    1. Sarah Buckholtz Post Author

      We love Natchez! Mike likes to ride out there. No site for the picks — they are sold in store on a first come first serve basis. You aren’t missing out, we’ll be here for a while. 🙂


    I Mike & Frank , my wife and I visited your store in Nashville and enjoyed it very much , we even ended up buying a few items not to mention post cards , etc and that was 3 or 4 years ago so next year , we’re planning on a vacation to LaClaire and Walcott (around maybe April 2020) we want to buy some of your DVD’s and maybe get you to autograpgh them for us IF we’re lucky enough to get to meet you . I could turn you on to some places in Arkansas . Hope to see you next year , be safe on your travels , God Bless you both …………………..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.